e-flux Conversations has been closed to new contributions and will remain online as an archive. Check out our new platform for short-form writing, e-flux Notes.

e-flux conversations

How online marketers pioneered modern surveillance

In a piece entitled “Commercial Surveillance State” published at the n+1 website, Matthew Crain and Anthony Nadler detail the myriad ways that internet marketing companies laid the groundwork for modern digital surveillance. As Crain and Nadler write, these companies not only pioneered techniques for tracking and influencing users’ internet behavior; they also worked to ensure that government policy would allow them to gather this data unhindered. Read an excerpt from their piece below:

The tactics of carefully targeted, data-driven manipulation—though innovative and destabilizing—are not entirely new. They predate the existence of Cambridge Analytica, and Facebook, and the contemporary notion of “fake news” itself. For decades, digital marketers—working in both commercial and political domains—have been perfecting models for using consumer data to identify and manipulate decision-making vulnerabilities. New marketing techniques have been developed with an astounding level of sophistication and duplicity: the particular exploits of Cambridge Analytica and its contemporaries depend upon a matrix of data collection and targeted communications, the primary purpose of which is not to influence politics but to increase the power of marketing. Call it an infrastructure for commercial surveillance: the technologies, companies, and, importantly, public policies that enable behavioral engineering over digital networks. One of the central threads of today’s internet is a shared capacity among businesses to collect and exchange user information. In the ocean of big data, no company is an island.

In her investigative reporting for the Guardian earlier this year, Carole Cadwalladr revealed how Cambridge Analytica partners with digital marketers and tech companies at key stages in its workflow. Detailed consumer information is readily obtained from any number of commercial data brokers. Firms like Experian and Acxiom compile rich profiles on literally all US households and specialize in merging disparate data sets in order to make them actionable for their clients. To collect information firsthand, Cambridge Analytica need only tap into a platform like Facebook, which also serves a means for distributing targeting messages. The entanglement is deep enough that it is hard to imagine how Cambridge Analytica could function without access to commercial data pipelines and communication channels.

Image of Facebook headquarters via Mashable.